Difference between revisions of "RDA Matching Options"
From AC Wiki
(→rda matching options) |
(→rda matching options) |
||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
| style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | | style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 100 || | + | | 100 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 110 || | + | | 110 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 111 || | + | | 111 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 130 || | + | | 130 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | ||
Line 39: | Line 39: | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 700 || | + | | 700 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 710 || | + | | 710 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 711 || | + | | 711 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 730 || | + | | 730 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 800 || | + | | 800 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 810 || | + | | 810 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 811 || | + | | 811 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 830 || | + | | 830 || 1st || never || 1st || never |
|} | |} | ||
Line 71: | Line 71: | ||
| style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | | style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 100 || | + | | 100 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 110 || | + | | 110 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 111 || | + | | 111 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 130 || | + | | 130 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | never | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | never | ||
Line 93: | Line 93: | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | never | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | never | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 700 || | + | | 700 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 710 || | + | | 710 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 711 || | + | | 711 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 730 || | + | | 730 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 800 || | + | | 800 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 810 || | + | | 810 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 811 || | + | | 811 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 830 || | + | | 830 || 1st || never || colspan="2" | never |
|} | |} | ||
Line 114: | Line 114: | ||
{| border="1" cellpadding="5" cellspacing="0" align="left" | {| border="1" cellpadding="5" cellspacing="0" align="left" | ||
+ | |+ | ||
|+ '''RDA AC: Option 3 Matching''' | |+ '''RDA AC: Option 3 Matching''' | ||
|- | |- | ||
Line 125: | Line 126: | ||
| style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | | style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 100 || | + | | 100 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 110 || | + | | 110 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 111 || | + | | 111 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 130 || | + | | 130 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | ||
Line 147: | Line 148: | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 700 || | + | | 700 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 710 || | + | | 710 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 711 || | + | | 711 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 730 || | + | | 730 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 800 || | + | | 800 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 810 || | + | | 810 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 811 || | + | | 811 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 830 || | + | | 830 || 1st || never || never || 1st |
|} | |} | ||
Line 180: | Line 181: | ||
| style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | | style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 100 || | + | | 100 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 110 || | + | | 110 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 111 || | + | | 111 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 130 || | + | | 130 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | ||
Line 202: | Line 203: | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 700 || | + | | 700 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 710 || | + | | 710 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 711 || | + | | 711 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 730 || | + | | 730 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 800 || | + | | 800 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 810 || | + | | 810 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 811 || | + | | 811 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 830 || | + | | 830 || 1st || 2nd || 1st || 2nd |
|} | |} | ||
Line 235: | Line 236: | ||
| style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | | style="background: #ffdead;" | Match RDA | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 100 || | + | | 100 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 110 || | + | | 110 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 111 || | + | | 111 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D4F5D3;" | ||
− | | 130 || | + | | 130 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #D3ECF5;" | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 600 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | ||
Line 257: | Line 258: | ||
| colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | | colspan="1" style="text-align: center;" | 655 || colspan="2" | both || colspan="2" | both | ||
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 700 || | + | | 700 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 710 || | + | | 710 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 711 || | + | | 711 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | |- align="center" style="background: #EED3F5;" | ||
− | | 730 || | + | | 730 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 800 || | + | | 800 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 810 || | + | | 810 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 811 || | + | | 811 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | |- align="center" style="background: #F5F4D3;" | ||
− | | 830 || | + | | 830 || 1st || 2nd || 2nd|| 1st |
|} | |} | ||
<div style=clear:both></div><br> | <div style=clear:both></div><br> |
Revision as of 12:30, 2 August 2012
RDA MATCHING OVERVIEW
In order to illustrate how each field is matched during authority control for AACR2 & RDA bib headings, we created this table for each of the 5 options we currently offer.
Note that the 6XX fields are all searched against AACR2 and RDA authority records simultaneously (except for Option 2).
rda matching options
AACR2 Records | RDA Records | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Field | Match AACR2 | Match RDA | Match AACR2 | Match RDA |
100 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
110 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
111 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
130 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
600 | both | both | ||
610 | both | both | ||
611 | both | both | ||
630 | both | both | ||
650 | both | both | ||
651 | both | both | ||
655 | both | both | ||
700 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
710 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
711 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
730 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
800 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
810 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
811 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
830 | 1st | never | 1st | never |
AACR2 Records | RDA Records | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Field | Match AACR2 | Match RDA | Match AACR2 | Match RDA |
100 | 1st | never | never | |
110 | 1st | never | never | |
111 | 1st | never | never | |
130 | 1st | never | never | |
600 | both | never | ||
610 | both | never | ||
611 | both | never | ||
630 | both | never | ||
650 | both | never | ||
651 | both | never | ||
655 | both | never | ||
700 | 1st | never | never | |
710 | 1st | never | never | |
711 | 1st | never | never | |
730 | 1st | never | never | |
800 | 1st | never | never | |
810 | 1st | never | never | |
811 | 1st | never | never | |
830 | 1st | never | never |
AACR2 Records | RDA Records | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Field | Match AACR2 | Match RDA | Match AACR2 | Match RDA |
100 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
110 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
111 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
130 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
600 | both | both | ||
610 | both | both | ||
611 | both | both | ||
630 | both | both | ||
650 | both | both | ||
651 | both | both | ||
655 | both | both | ||
700 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
710 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
711 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
730 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
800 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
810 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
811 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
830 | 1st | never | never | 1st |
AACR2 Records | RDA Records | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Field | Match AACR2 | Match RDA | Match AACR2 | Match RDA |
100 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
110 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
111 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
130 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
600 | both | both | ||
610 | both | both | ||
611 | both | both | ||
630 | both | both | ||
650 | both | both | ||
651 | both | both | ||
655 | both | both | ||
700 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
710 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
711 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
730 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
800 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
810 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
811 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
830 | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 2nd |
AACR2 Records | RDA Records | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Field | Match AACR2 | Match RDA | Match AACR2 | Match RDA |
100 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
110 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
111 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
130 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
600 | both | both | ||
610 | both | both | ||
611 | both | both | ||
630 | both | both | ||
650 | both | both | ||
651 | both | both | ||
655 | both | both | ||
700 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
710 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
711 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
730 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
800 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
810 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
811 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |
830 | 1st | 2nd | 2nd | 1st |